| Season | Date | Score | Most Valuable Players | Venue
|
| 1938 | January 15, 1939 | New York Giants 13, Pro All-Stars 10 | (No MVP until 1950) | Wrigley Field, Los Angeles
|
| 1939 | January 14, 1940 | Green Bay Packers 16, NFL All-Stars 7 | (No MVP until 1950) | Gilmore Stadium, Los Angeles
|
| 1940 | December 29, 1940 | Chicago Bears 28, NFL All-Stars 14 | (No MVP until 1950) | Gilmore Stadium, Los Angeles
|
| 1941 | January 4, 1942 | Chicago Bears 35, NFL All-Stars 24 | (No MVP until 1950) | Polo Grounds, New York City
|
| 1942 | December 27, 1942 | NFL All-Stars 17, Washington Redskins 14 | (No MVP until 1950) | Shibe Park, Philadelphia
|
| 1943 | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II
|
| 1944 | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II
|
| 1945 | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II
|
| 1946 | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II
|
| 1947 | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II
|
| 1948 | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II
|
| 1949 | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II | NO PRO BOWL GAME DUE TO WORLD WAR II
|
| 1950 | January 14, 1951 | American Conference 28, National Conference 27 | Otto Graham, Browns, Quarterback | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1951 | January 12, 1952 | National Conference 30, American Conference 13 | Dan Towler, Rams Running back | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1952 | January 10, 1953 | National Conference 27, American Conference 7 | Don Doll, Lions, Defensive back | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1953 | January 17, 1954 | East 20, West 9 | Chuck Bednarik, Eagles, Linebacker | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1954 | January 16, 1955 | West 26, East 19 | Billy Wilson, 49ers, End | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1955 | January 15, 1956 | East 31, West 30 | Ollie Matson, Cardinals, Running back | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1956 | January 13, 1957 | West 19, East 10 | Back: Bert Rechichar, Colts
Lineman: Ernie Stautner, Steelers | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1957 | January 12, 1958 | West 26, East 7 | Back: Hugh McElhenny, 49ers
Lineman: Gene Brito, Redskins | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1958 | January 11, 1959 | East 28, West 21 | Back: Frank Gifford, NY Giants
Lineman: Doug Atkins, Bears | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1959 | January 17, 1960 | West 38, East 21 | Back: Johnny Unitas, Colts
Lineman: Eugene "Big Daddy" Lipscomb, Steelers | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1960 | January 15, 1961 | West 35, East 31 | Back: Johnny Unitas, Colts
Lineman: Sam Huff, NY Giants | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1961 | January 14, 1962 | West 31, East 30 | Back: Jim Brown, Browns
Lineman: Henry Jordan, Packers | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1962 | January 13, 1963 | East 30, West 20 | Back: Jim Brown, Browns
Lineman: Eugene "Big Daddy" Lipscomb, Steelers | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1963 | January 12, 1964 | West 31, East 17 | Back: Johnny Unitas, Colts
Lineman: Gino Marchetti, Colts | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1964 | January 10, 1965 | West 34, East 14 | Back: Fran Tarkenton, Vikings
Lineman: Terry Barr, Lions | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1965 | January 15, 1966 | East 36, West 7 | Back: Jim Brown, Browns
Lineman: Dale Meinert, Cardinals | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1966 | January 22, 1967 | East 20, West 10 | Back: Gale Sayers, Bears
Lineman: Floyd Peters, Eagles | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1967 | January 21, 1968 | West 38, East 20 | Back: Gale Sayers, Bears
Lineman: Dave Robinson, Packers | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1968 | January 19, 1969 | West 10, East 7 | Back: Roman Gabriel, Rams
Lineman: Merlin Olsen, Rams | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1969 | January 18, 1970 | West 16, East 13 | Back: Gale Sayers, Bears
Lineman: George Andrie, Cowboys | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1970-71 | January 24, 1971 | NFC, 27-6 | Back: Mel Renfro, Cowboys
Lineman: Fred Carr, Packers | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1971-72 | January 23, 1972 | AFC, 26-13 | Offense: Jan Stenerud, Chiefs
Defense: Willie Lanier, Chiefs | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1972-73 | January 21, 1973 | AFC, 33-28 | O.J. Simpson, Bills, Running back | Texas Stadium, Irving, Texas
|
| 1973-74 | January 20, 1974 | AFC, 15-13 | Garo Yepremian, Dolphins, Placekicker | Arrowhead Stadium, Kansas City, Missouri
|
| 1974-75 | January 20, 1975 | NFC, 17-10 | James Harris, Rams, Quarterback | Miami Orange Bowl
|
| 1975-76 | January 26, 1976 | NFC, 23-20 | Billy Johnson, Oilers, Kick returner | Louisiana Superdome, New Orleans, Louisiana
|
| 1976-77 | January 17, 1977 | AFC, 24-14 | Mel Blount, Steelers, Cornerback | The Kingdome, Seattle, Washington
|
| 1977-78 | January 23, 1978 | NFC, 14-13 | Walter Payton, Bears, Running back | Tampa Stadium
|
| 1978-79 | January 29, 1979 | NFC, 13-7 | Ahmad Rashad, Vikings, Wide receiver | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum
|
| 1979-80 | January 27, 1980 | NFC, 37-27 | Chuck Muncie, Saints, Running back | Aloha Stadium, Honolulu, Hawaii
|
| 1980-81 | February 1, 1981 | NFC, 21-7 | Eddie Murray, Lions, Placekicker | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1981-82 | January 31, 1982 | AFC, 16-13 | Kellen Winslow, Chargers, Tight end
Lee Roy Selmon, Buccaneers, Defensive end | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1982-83 | February 6, 1983 | NFC, 20-19 | Dan Fouts, Chargers, Quarterback
John Jefferson, Packers, Wide receiver | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1983-84 | January 29, 1984 | NFC, 45-3 | Joe Theismann, Redskins, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1984-85 | January 27, 1985 | AFC, 22-14 | Mark Gastineau, Jets, Defensive end | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1985-86 | February 2, 1986 | NFC, 28-24 | Phil Simms, Giants, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1986-87 | February 1, 1987 | AFC, 10-6 | Reggie White, Eagles, Defensive end | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1987-88 | February 7, 1988 | AFC, 15-6 | Bruce Smith, Bills, Defensive end | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1988-89 | January 29, 1989 | NFC, 34-3 | Randall Cunningham, Eagles, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1989-90 | February 4, 1990 | NFC, 27-21 | Jerry Gray, Rams, Cornerback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1990-91 | February 3, 1991 | AFC, 23-21 | Jim Kelly, Bills, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1991-92 | February 2, 1992 | NFC, 21-15 | Michael Irvin, Cowboys, Wide receiver | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1992-93 | February 7, 1993 | AFC, 23-20 (OT) | Steve Tasker, Bills, Special teams | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1993-94 | February 6, 1994 | NFC, 17-3 | Andre Rison, Falcons, Wide receiver | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1994-95 | February 5, 1995 | AFC, 41-13 | Marshall Faulk, Colts, Running back | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1995-96 | February 4, 1996 | NFC, 20-13 | Jerry Rice, 49ers, Wide receiver | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1996-97 | February 2, 1997 | AFC, 26-23 (OT) | Mark Brunell, Jaguars, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1997-98 | February 1, 1998 | AFC, 29-24 | Warren Moon, Seahawks, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1998-99 | February 7, 1999 | AFC, 23-10 | Ty Law, Patriots, Cornerback
Keyshawn Johnson, Jets, Wide receiver | Aloha Stadium
|
| 1999-00 | February 6, 2000 | NFC, 51-31 | Randy Moss, Vikings, Wide receiver | Aloha Stadium
|
| 2000-01 | February 4, 2001 | AFC, 38-17 | Rich Gannon, Raiders, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 2001-02 | February 10, 2002 | AFC, 38-30 | Rich Gannon, Raiders, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 2002-03 | February 2, 2003 | AFC, 45-20 | Ricky Williams, Dolphins, Running back | Aloha Stadium
|
| 2003-04 | February 8, 2004 | NFC, 55-52 | Marc Bulger, Rams, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 2004-05 | February 13, 2005 | AFC, 38-27 | Peyton Manning, Colts, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 2005-06 | February 12, 2006 | NFC 23-17 | Derrick Brooks, Buccaneers, Linebacker | Aloha Stadium
|
| 2006-07 | February 10, 2007 | AFC 31-28 | Carson Palmer, Bengals, Quarterback | Aloha Stadium
|
| 2007-08 | February 10, 2008 | AFC vs. NFC | TBD | Aloha Stadium
|
